Why the choice matters in Geneva
Geneva is one of Europe's leading wealth management centres: alongside the large private banks, many independent portfolio managers operate in the city. For a private investor the real question is not "bank or no bank" — the assets always stay at a bank — but who takes the investment decisions, and with which incentives.
The model in brief
With a traditional bank, custody, advice and products sit in the same institution. With an independent manager, custody stays at a Swiss custodian bank in an account in your name, while the manager holds a limited management mandate: it can trade the portfolio but cannot withdraw or transfer funds.
Side-by-side comparison
| Traditional bank | Independent manager | |
|---|---|---|
| Custody of assets | At the bank itself | At a Swiss custodian bank, in an account in the client's name |
| Products | In-house funds and products are often favoured | Open architecture, no proprietary products to place |
| Costs | Sometimes embedded in products and less visible | Explicit management fee, separate and legible costs |
| Point of contact | Relationship manager who may change with internal reorganisations | Direct access to the person managing the portfolio |
| Supervision | FINMA (banking licence) | FINMA (FinIA licence) + supervisory organisation |
| Flexibility | Standardised processes, higher minimums | Tailored mandate, more flexibility |
Regulation: what changed in 2020
Under the Financial Institutions Act (FinIA) and the Financial Services Act (FinSA), in force since 1 January 2020, independent portfolio managers need a licence from FINMA and are supervised by an authorised supervisory organisation. They must follow conduct rules, cost transparency and conflict-of-interest requirements.
When a bank can be the right choice
- You need Lombard credit, mortgages or integrated banking in the same institution.
- You prefer a single counterparty for everything, even at the cost of less independence.
When an independent manager makes sense
- You want explicit costs and no incentive to place products.
- You value continuity with the person actually managing the portfolio.
- You want to be able to change manager without moving your assets.
Questions to ask before signing
- Which custodian bank, and in whose name is the account?
- What is the all-in annual cost, as a percentage?
- Are there retrocessions, and how are they handled?
- Who actually manages my portfolio, and who covers for them?
Read more about my approach to wealth management in Geneva and discretionary mandates. If you live abroad, see also the guide to investing as a non-resident.
General information only; not financial, legal or tax advice.